TCGIndexTCGIndex
Painful Quandary
Magic: The Gathering · Rare

Painful Quandary

$1.97
-$0.07-3.5% · 30D
Aggregated from verified sold data · eBay, TCGplayer & PriceCharting
Where these prices come from

Magic: The Gathering prices on TCGIndex are TCGplayer market prices (the US market), in US dollars, with graded and sold prices from PriceCharting and eBay. Another currency is a conversion from USD at the day's rate, not a European market price. We do not use Cardmarket or Cardtrader prices for Magic: The Gathering.

Market Health
Excellent
Strong demand
Confidence
82/100
High reliability
Liquidity
High
Active market
Verified Sales
143
Updated 2h ago
Buy

We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through our eBay & TCGplayer links.

Model signal
Before the price moves

We find the Magic: The Gathering cards about to rise.

Every night the model scores every Magic card on the market. Every morning at 07:30 UTC it publishes the one most likely to gain 10% within 30 days, with its entry price and the reasons, then scores it in public.

See today’s Magic pick

Published this morning, public in 14 days. Full record

Price & Volume
Market price Sales volume
Jul 2026 – today
Sales & Liquidity
Market Price$1.97
7-Day Change+8.2%
90-Day Change+28.8%
LiquidityHigh
Market TrendStable
Price by Condition · 10
Anchored to market price · condition spread from TCGplayer
Near Mint
Foil · English
$1.97
+6.5%
Near Mint
Normal · English
$1.28
-2.0%
Lightly Played
Normal · English
$1.19
-2.8%
Lightly Played
Foil · English
$1.45
+1.8%
Moderately Played
Normal · English
$1.07
+2.5%
Moderately Played
Foil · English
$1.32
+7.7%
Heavily Played
Normal · English
$0.88
+12.1%
Heavily Played
Foil · English
$0.45
Damaged
Normal · English
$1.35
+6.8%
Damaged
Foil · English
$0.86
+0.0%

Painful Quandary price history

Near Mint market priceon the dates below, from TCGIndex's daily record (104 days tracked). High $2.29 on Oct 2026, low $1.51 on Jul 2026.

WhenPricevs today
Today$2.29
7 days ago$2.14+7.0%
30 days ago$1.56+46.8%
90 days ago$1.82+25.8%
6 months ago$1.74+31.6%
MonthMonth-end price
Jan 2026$1.91
Feb 2026$1.89
Mar 2026$1.81
Apr 2026$1.74
May 2026$1.60
Jun 2026$1.59
Jul 2026$1.70
Aug 2026$1.63
Sep 2026$1.66
Oct 2026$2.29

Painful Quandary FAQ

How much is Painful Quandary worth right now?
Painful Quandary from The Brothers' War is trading around $1.97 raw (ungraded) on the secondary market. TCGIndex refreshes this price every day.
Is Painful Quandary going up or down?
Painful Quandary is down -3.5% over 30 days, up +8.2% over 7 days. The full price history is on this page.
Is Painful Quandary a good investment?
TCGIndex doesn't give financial advice, but here's the data worth knowing: it sits around $1.97, down -3.5% over the last 30 days, with low volatility. Prices can move fast, so look at the trend and your own timeframe before you buy. TCGIndex publishes one Magic: The Gathering pick every morning; each pick becomes public 14 days later and is scored at day 30.