TCGIndexTCGIndex
Chthonian Nightmare (Retro Frame)
Magic: The Gathering · Rare

Chthonian Nightmare (Retro Frame)

406Modern Horizons 3
$19.95
+$0.15+0.8% · 30D
Aggregated from verified sold data · eBay, TCGplayer & PriceCharting
Where these prices come from

Magic: The Gathering prices on TCGIndex are TCGplayer market prices (the US market), in US dollars, with graded and sold prices from PriceCharting and eBay. Another currency is a conversion from USD at the day's rate, not a European market price. We do not use Cardmarket or Cardtrader prices for Magic: The Gathering.

Market Health
Excellent
Strong demand
Confidence
74/100
Reliable
Liquidity
Medium
Moderate activity
Verified Sales
54
Updated 7h ago
Buy

We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through our eBay & TCGplayer links.

Model signal
Before the price moves

We find the Magic: The Gathering cards about to rise.

Every night the model scores every Magic card on the market. Every morning at 07:30 UTC it publishes the one most likely to gain 10% within 30 days, with its entry price and the reasons, then scores it in public.

See today’s Magic pick

Published this morning, public in 14 days. Full record

Price & Volume
Market price Sales volume
Jul 2026 – today
Sales & Liquidity
Market Price$19.95
7-Day Change-1.5%
90-Day Change—
LiquidityMedium
Market TrendStable
Price by Grade
CGC 10$11·
PSA 9$9·
Raw· 54 sales$2·
Price by Condition · 8
Anchored to market price · condition spread from TCGplayer
Near Mint
Foil - Japanese · Japanese
$19.95
Near Mint
Foil · English
$4.70
+1.7%
Near Mint
Normal · English
$1.63
+1.2%
Lightly Played
Normal · English
$1.31
-1.5%
Lightly Played
Foil · English
$4.05
-0.7%
Moderately Played
Normal · English
$1.93
+4.9%
Moderately Played
Foil · English
$3.55
Damaged
Normal · English
$1.34

Chthonian Nightmare (Retro Frame) price history

Near Mint market priceon the dates below, from TCGIndex's daily record (25 days tracked).

WhenPricevs today
Today$19.95
7 days ago$19.95+0.0%

Chthonian Nightmare (Retro Frame) PSA 10 price and graded values

What Chthonian Nightmare (Retro Frame) (Modern Horizons 3) sells for by grade, from verified sold listings.

GradeMarket price
Raw (ungraded)$1.96
PSA 9$8.50
CGC 10$10.50

Graded prices: PriceCharting sold data, refreshed daily. Grading costs, turnaround and the odds of a 10 decide whether the premium is worth chasing. Most valuable Magic: The Gathering PSA 10 cards

Chthonian Nightmare (Retro Frame) FAQ

How much is Chthonian Nightmare (Retro Frame) worth right now?
Chthonian Nightmare (Retro Frame) from Modern Horizons 3 is trading around $19.95 raw (ungraded) on the secondary market. TCGIndex refreshes this price every day.
Is Chthonian Nightmare (Retro Frame) going up or down?
Chthonian Nightmare (Retro Frame) is up +0.8% over 30 days, down -1.5% over 7 days. The full price history is on this page.
Is Chthonian Nightmare (Retro Frame) a good investment?
TCGIndex doesn't give financial advice, but here's the data worth knowing: it sits around $19.95, up +0.8% over the last 30 days, with low volatility. Prices can move fast, so look at the trend and your own timeframe before you buy. TCGIndex publishes one Magic: The Gathering pick every morning; each pick becomes public 14 days later and is scored at day 30.

More cards from Modern Horizons 3

Ulamog, the Defiler (Borderless) (Serial Numbered)Ulamog, the Defiler (Borderless)Polluted Delta (Retro Frame)Flooded Strand (Retro Frame)Wooded Foothills (Retro Frame)Phyrexian Tower (Borderless)Bloodstained Mire (Borderless)Modern Horizons 3 - Prerelease PackOcelot Pride (Borderless)Windswept Heath (Retro Frame)Emrakul, the World Anew (Borderless)Tamiyo, Inquisitive Student (Borderless) (Textured Foil)Ral, Monsoon Mage (Borderless) (Textured Foil)Ajani, Nacatl Pariah (Borderless) (Textured Foil)Kaalia of the Vast (0343) (Borderless)Warren Soultrader (Retro Frame)Ocelot Pride (Retro Frame)Sorin of House Markov (Borderless) (Textured Foil)Flare of Fortitude (Borderless)Ocelot PrideFlare of Duplication (Borderless)Polluted Delta (Borderless)Flare of Denial (Borderless)Polluted Delta (Extended Art)
View the full Modern Horizons 3 set →